
Sheraton Resort on Sand Key
Best for families or groups who want private Gulf-front beach access and multiple on-site dining and event spaces.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Sheraton Resort on Sand Key is a large, family-friendly Marriott beachfront resort on Sand Key with private Gulf-front beach and multiple on-site restaurants — a fit for families and groups who want resort amenities and easy beach access. Fenway Hotel Autograph Collection is a 4-star historic boutique Autograph Collection hotel in downtown Dunedin that attracts Marriott-loyal travelers and visitors seeking a compact, characterful base north of Clearwater Beach.
Updated · about 12 mi apart

Best for families or groups who want private Gulf-front beach access and multiple on-site dining and event spaces.

Best for travelers who prefer a smaller, historic boutique hotel in downtown Dunedin within easy reach of the marina and local restaurants.
When Sheraton Resort on Sand Key wins: choose Sheraton if you want a full-service beachfront resort with a heated beachfront pool, a separate children's pool and whirlpool, multiple casual and full-service dining outlets, extensive meeting/wedding space, and easy beach and water-activity access for families.
When Fenway Hotel Autograph Collection wins: choose Fenway if you want a compact, historic Autograph Collection property in Dunedin with boutique character, onsite HEW Parlor & Chophouse and a walkable downtown/marina location for restaurants, ballpark events, and local sightseeing.
Bottom line: pick Sheraton for a traditional, amenity-rich seaside resort experience and Fenway Hotel for a smaller historic-boutique stay north of Clearwater Beach that’s better suited to adults or couples seeking a downtown base.
| Category | Sheraton Resort on Sand Key | Fenway Hotel Autograph Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Large beachfront resort, family-focused and activity-rich | Historic boutique hotel with downtown Dunedin character |
| Location | Sand Key / Clearwater Beach, private Gulf-front beach | Downtown Dunedin, near the marina and local shops |
| Size | ~375–390 rooms across multiple buildings | 83 rooms |
| Ages / audience | All ages; family resort (children welcome) | All ages welcome; not adults-only (family-friendly listing) |
| Pools & beach | Heated outdoor beachfront pool, children's pool, whirlpool/hot tub | One outdoor pool; near the beach (not listed as private beachfront) |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues (Rusty's Bistro, Mainstay Tavern, Slo Joe's Turtle Bar, Poolside Café) | HEW Parlor & Chophouse plus a snack bar/deli and a bar/lounge |
| Spa & wellness | No verified on-site spa (nearby salons noted) | Not published |
| Meeting & events | Extensive event space (roughly 20K–24K sq ft) plus large beach event capacities | Conference space ~9,560 sq ft and 3 meeting rooms |
| Signature features | 13 acres private Gulf-front beach, family activities, large ballrooms for weddings | Historic Autograph Collection property, rooftop garden/terrace and proximity to TD Ballpark |
| Nearby airports | St. Pete-Clearwater Intl. (PIE) ~20–27 min drive; Tampa Intl. ~30–40 min | St. Pete-Clearwater Intl. (PIE) 13.1 mi / 21.1 km; Tampa Intl. ~33.9 km / 21.1 mi |
Sheraton Resort on Sand Key sits on Sand Key with its own private Gulf-front beach and short links to Clearwater Beach and local nature trails.
Sheraton is for travelers prioritizing direct beach access and resort-side activities.
Fenway Hotel is located on Edgewater Drive in downtown Dunedin near the marina, ballpark and local restaurants.
Fenway suits guests who want a compact downtown base with access to Dunedin’s waterfront and venues.
Sheraton has many room types across a large property, with many rooms offering private balconies or patio views.
Sheraton offers a wide selection of room types for families and groups needing space and views.
Fenway has 83 air-conditioned rooms and suites with standard boutique-hotel comforts.
Fenway is better for travelers who prefer a smaller set of guestrooms in a restored historic building.
Sheraton has several on-site dining options covering breakfast, casual poolside snacks and full dinners.
Sheraton is convenient for families and guests who want variety and pool-to-plate options without leaving property.
Fenway offers an on-site signature restaurant plus lighter on-property food options.
Fenway is for travelers who expect a focused dining program and want to explore Dunedin’s restaurants.
The Sheraton’s headline amenity is its private Gulf-front beach plus multiple pool options.
The Sheraton is a beach-and-pool resort built around family-friendly water access.
Fenway has one outdoor pool and is described as being near the beach rather than directly beachfront.
Fenway provides a compact pool offering and relies on nearby waterfronts for beach time.
Sheraton supports activity with a 24-hour fitness center and beachside bars for casual evening options.
Sheraton suits guests wanting fitness options plus casual resort nightlife and easy access to outdoor activities.
Fenway offers a 24-hour fitness center and an on-site bar/lounge but no published full-service spa in supplier listing.
Fenway fits travelers who want compact fitness/wine-and-dine options and to explore Dunedin after dark.

Sheraton Resort on Sand Key — private Gulf-front beach and direct beach access from the property.

Fenway Hotel Autograph Collection — historic Autograph Collection property with downtown Dunedin charm.

Sheraton Resort on Sand Key — extensive meeting and ballroom space plus large outdoor beach venues for weddings.

Fenway Hotel Autograph Collection — smaller footprint, walkable to the marina, TD Ballpark and downtown Dunedin dining.
Sheraton Resort on Sand Key — it’s marketed as family-friendly, has a children’s pool, family-friendly dining and kids-stays-free policies.
Sheraton Resort on Sand Key is on Sand Key with direct beach access and a short ride to Clearwater Beach; Fenway is in Dunedin, a drive north of Clearwater Beach.
No — Fenway’s supplier listing indicates it welcomes guests of all sexual orientations and gender identities; it is not listed as adults-only.
No verified on-site spa with a name and treatment menu was found for Sheraton; nearby salons and spas operate in the area.
Explore how Sheraton Resort on Sand Key stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·